What is the best format for music and audio files?

What is the best format for music and audio files?

We’ve been through a lot of different mediums for storing our music over the years, from classic vinyl records to modern MP3s. But what is the best format for audio and digital music files? Obviously nothing will compare to the feeling of hearing a band play music live, but what’s the next best thing?

Some of our readers may remember the days of vinyl records and cassette tapes, but our younger readers may only know CDs and MP3s. It’s easy to just wave this off as advancing technology, but in truth sometimes the old ways were the best, at least when it comes to pure audio quality.  At the same time, portability is a huge bonus and being able to listen to music on the go is well worth a slight downgrade for most people. If you have old CDs lying around that you want to convert to MP3 files, you should looking into the best audio converter software. And obviously many of the best headphones will enhance your music further, if you're willing to pay for them.

Vinyl Records

There are still people out there holding fast to their vinyl records, who won't give them up for anything. But why is that? Especially for those of you in the younger generations, what could a record have over an iPod? Is it just nostalgia?

You may like

The truth of the matter is records in good condition have a higher sound quality than any other medium - even better than a modern CD or DVD. This is because the vinyl can pick up every single part of the sound wave. No information is lost. The records will hold the scale of the sound and you will get everything. If you want the true sound of your music, then records are the way to go. The downside is a small speck of dust or scratch will create noise and static.

Cassette Tapes

While many music enthusiasts consider cassette tapes to be an embarrassment to the audio field, they had a use. While a few old cars actually squeezed a record player onto their dashboard, cassettes were a lot easier to deal with on the go. 

They were much more compact and resistant to bumpy roads, and anyone could record with them. However, the sound quality on the majority of them left a lot to be desired, and you can't forget about the tape-eating machines. Cassettes were great for portability, but few people minded when something better came along. These days there is very little reason to favor cassette tapes unless you have an old car that doesn’t have a CD player.

if you need to update your old cassettes to a more modern format, check out our best cassette to MP3 converters guide.

CDs

This is one of the first digital methods of storing audio available to the public and it didn't take much encouragement for people to leave their cassettes behind and purchase CDs. Not only did the audio sound cleaner, but CDs lasted longer since nothing actually touched the disc and wore it down. 

Though the sound quality is better than cassettes, it still doesn’t hold a candle to the vinyl records. This is because a digital file only captures some of the data. Despite this, the majority of people aren’t too bothered by the difference as you only lose a small portion of the audio data. Though CDs are still being manufactured, they too are starting to fall by the wayside as people turn increasingly towards digital media and streaming.

MP3

Easily the most popular and commonly used audio format these days, MP3s are purely digital files that can be stored, transferred between and played directly from your devices. By storing our music directly onto hard drives, we can now store thousands of songs without needing to litter our homes with shelving units.

But sacrifices have been made in the name of progress, and MP3 files sacrifice the range and quality in exchange for the convenience of small file sizes. This means that we get reduced audio quality when compared with something like vinyl. 

The upside of this is that you don’t need to strap a gramophone to your back if you want to listen to some tunes when you go out for a run - instead you can just upload some MP3s to your smartphone and you're good to go.

Few options can even come close to the quality of a vinyl record. However, with this rapidly advancing technological society, many are willing to sacrifice that to carry more of their music around with them.

Ian Stokes

Ian Stokes is the Tech Editor here at Top Ten Reviews. He has extensive experience in tech and games journalism, with work published on IGN, Kotaku UK, Waypoint, GamesRadar, Trusted Reviews, and many more. You'll find him covering everything from smartphones and home computers to 3D printers and headphones. He's also our resident cocktail expert.

Read more
best cassette to mp3 players
Best cassette to MP3 converters 2025: convenient devices to preserve audio memories
Kodak Scanza being tested
Best slide to digital image converters 2025: to preserve precious memories, tried and tested
Close-up of unrecognizable woman selecting DVD to watch
Best DVD players 2025: affordable wide-compatibility players for your physical media collection
Canon PIXMA TS6420a Wireless All-In-One Inkjet Printer being tested in writer's home
Best compact printers 2025: space-saving devices for your home office, tried and tested
Coleman RoadTrip X-cursion LXE being ignited by writer during testing
Gas grills vs. pellet grills: which is right for you?
Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Grill & Smoker
Gas grills vs. electric grills: which is right for you?
Latest in Electronics
Empty living room with projector screen with projection set up with couch and cushions and lights hanging on wall and floor
How to use a mini projector: your step-by-step guide for creating your own at-home theater
ReMarkable 2 tablet
ReMarkable 2 review: a handy doodle pad for notes and more
The ONYX BOOX Tab C Ultra on a table surrounded by lamps.
ONYX BOOX Tab Ultra C review
Man using a tablet with a keyboard on his lap on a train.
What is the best tablet with a keyboard?
Kodak Scanza
Kodak Scanza Digital Film & Slide Scanner review
Person typing on a laptop on a desk with cup of tea next to it.
I leveled up my organization by discovering how to change desktop icons
Latest in Feature
Things you shouldn't put in a dishwasher
Do dishwashers use a lot of electricity?
What does energy efficient mean?
Do washing machines use a lot of electricity?
Best Dishwasher
Bosch vs Miele dishwashers: which is right for you?
Shopping for dishwasher
Are all dishwashers the same size? Everything you need to know
Testing the Echo TC-210 Tiller in grass
Rear tine tiller vs front tine: which is better?
The Troy-Bilt Colt tiller is perfect for any type of garden bed.
Tiller vs aerator: which one has the edge?